Saadeh v Farouki

1997

Venue: DC Cir

Facts: Saadeh, a Greek ciizen loaned money to Farouki, a Jordanian residing in MD as a "permanent resident." He defaults, and Saadeh sues. While the suit is underway, Faruoki becomes a US citizen.

Posture: Judgment for Saadeh. Appeal. Ct. App. dismisses for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.

Issue: At the time the complaint was filed, was Farouki a "citizen of a state" under § 1332.

Holding: No. Dismissed.

Rule: We read the last sentence of § 1332(a) as contracting diversity, not expanding it.

Reasoning:

Dicta: