Wickard v. Filmore

1942

Venue: SCOTUS

Facts: Wickard raises winter wheat for his own consumption on his own farm. The Agricultural Adjustment Act says he has to pay a penalty for growing this surplus wheat.

Posture: Unspecified

Issue: Does Art. I § 8 give Congress the power to enact a law that regulates private use of home-grown crops under the umbrella of interstate commerce?

Holding: Yes.

Rule: Just because it's local doesn't mean it's not commerce, and congress is empowered to decide what affects interstate commerce, whether directly or indirectly.

Reasoning: Consumption of homegrown wheat causes variations in the availability of the crop on an interstate basis. Just because this one person's effect is small doesn't mean it's not real: if everyone did this, we'd have big troubles. Interstate wheat commerce is a big deal.

Dicta: