Lindsey v. Normet

1972

Venue: SCOTUS

Facts: OR statute requires a trial 6 days after a service of complaint for nonpayment of rent, and limits the triable issues to tenant's default, precluding defenses based on landlords breach of duty to maintain the premises.

Posture: Unknown

Issue: Does the OR eviction process violate 14A Equal Protection?

Holding: No.

Rule: Non-paying renters in poorly maintained houses are not a protected class.

Reasoning: The statute is for protection of landlords, but also tenants: it provides a speedy, judicially supervised proceeding.

The constitution doesn't address landlord-tenant relations, and it doesn't authorize courts to extend tenancy while damage claims against a landlord are litigated.

Therefore, this isn't like the constitutionally protected rights that require a strong justification in statutory purpose.


Dicta: Douglas (dissenting): there's a lot of poverty, and the home is important.