Tomic v. Catholic Diocese of Peoria

2006

Venue: 7th Cir

Facts: Organist gets fired.

Posture: Suit for age discrimination. District judge dismisses it.

Issue: Is the firing decision an ecclesiastical matter?

Holding: Yes.

Rule: We do not exercise jurisdiction over the internal affairs of religious organizations.

Reasoning: Discussion of the religious connotations and importance of music.

The church says it's an equal opportunity employer, but there's a ministerial exception to that, which can't really be waived (because the courts don't want to get into that mess).


Dicta: