Joseph v. San Francisco Housing Authority

2005

Court: CA Supreme Court

Facts: There's a fire at a SFHA building, and five people (four kids) die.

Posture: Jury finds SHFA liable for the deaths, awards $12M. Later there's some settling and insurance. But still, the plaintiffs didn't get paid. So they file a suit and SFHA says they don't have that kind of money. And they don't plan to negotiate.

Issue: Should they have to pay?

Holding: Yes.

Rule: CA law expressly requires public entities to pay the full amount of any judgment.

Reasoning: Nothing in the rules says they can't spend their HUD money on this. Or their city funds. Or they can raise money themselves by issuing bonds.

Dicta: